Adeline and I sit on the floor in her room, looking through her favorite books. We come to a page with a picture of a little bunny and a short poem about hopping around and eating grass. The bunny is grey and totally adorable.
“Look Addie, isn’t he so cute?”
Despite the fact that the bunny is completely gender neutral and there are no gender clues in the poem, I’ve automatically and without thinking made the bunny a boy. I do it all the time, even though I don’t want to, and I hate it.
I think the “he/she” or “he and/or she” formulations are awkward at best, and I used to shrug off the feminists who complained about the almost-exclusive use of ‘he’ in our culture. “What’s the harm?” I thought. But then I had a daughter. And, finally, I understood.
When I make every animal, character, and even anthropomorphic car a ‘he’, I’m giving my daughter a lesson: men are dominant in our culture. All the animals who are worth writing books about are boys. All the cars that are cool are boys. All the characters who have adventures and do amazing things are boys. Anyone who’s worth talking about is a boy. And you’re a girl. So good luck with that.
Of course, parents of boys aren’t exempt either. Boys learn those same lessons, and therefore come to believe that they are better than girls. We can’t expect our children to believe in equality if the unspoken messages that they receive are telling them that equality is a fairy tale. We all know by now that our actions are immensely more powerful than the lessons we try to teach. But our actions are also more habitual and unconscious and much harder to control.
I know I’m not the only one who falls into this trap. My mother and my mother-in-law are both intelligent, accomplished women, who are both feminists in their own ways. But I’ve watched and listened as both of them, completely unconsciously I’m sure, have sat with Addie and labelled toys and characters that aren’t obviously girls as ‘he’.
Which is it’s own lesson: the only girls are the ones who are obviously girls. They wear pink and have bows in their hair and have big doe eyes and long eyelashes and they strike poses and, well, you get the point. So how could Addie not then believe that in order to identify with her gender she has to be and do those things?
I know the obvious solutions: get her books with strong female characters, give her permission to wear whatever and look however she wants to, discourage Barbies, watch Brave instead of Sleeping Beauty. But the problem is more insidious than that. I need to change my language.
It’s not that easy, though. Even when I’m aware enough to call an animal or character ‘she’, it’s still a struggle. I want to do it. I believe it’s important and I know there’s no reason not to. Yet I still feel awkward doing it. ‘He’ is so ingrained in my psyche that I can’t get over it. I can’t get over “He’.
Do you struggle with this? Or do you think it’s no big deal? Or are you a gender-neutral pro? And if so, how do you do it??

Why don’t you just say “it”? Or give the neutral things real names. The car’s name is Carry. The bunny is Jane. Guess it’s the first time, that I see the advantage in having three articles instead of just “the”
That doesn’t give you a choice of the gender. And a lot of things carry the neutral article. Other than that: I don’t think that sticking to “he” affects her view on men and women in the future. No.
I’m a total gender neutral pro — just kidding! I do try to use ‘it’ as much as I can. I also TRY to refrain from making statements. Yes, that’s a bunny, what color is it? What does a bunny eat? – somehow it makes me less likely to assign a gender? Or maybe that’s just in my head.
At the end of the day, your awareness is going to be what makes the difference in Addie’s perception. The fact that you care so much is going to create a positive environment, full of open dialogue, a place where she can empower herself…
I have two boys and I have tried valiantly to assume all gender neutral figures are females. As a fire truck goes by too fast to see who is in it, I ask, “Do you think the lady driving that fire engine wears her helmet while she drives or does she wait until she gets to the fire?” I figure if I call every not-specifically-male thing a lady or a “her” then they will assume women can do everything. And they will not default to thinking they rule the world. Both results are good. And there are enough books with male leads that they will have plenty of opportunities to identify.
Other languages have a gender neutral pronoun that isn’t “it” but that means, basically, “person.” Wish we did, too.
I know – the gender neutral pronoun would make the whole thing so much easier! That’s impressive that you do that with boys. I always feel like as a mother of a girl things are so much harder, but I know that for someone who’s aware, parenting a boy is just as hard.
My lady boss shared her son’s experience in his first ever big quiz (he’s in kindergarten). The quiz was about who does what in the family. Her son apparently made a few wrong answers because he based everything on their family, and theirs is definitely not the conventional one. My lady boss sure thinks that education should start within her family but she also wishes that school-teachers should think twice before teaching anything that has something to do with ‘gender roles’.
Yeah, that’s crazy! School shouldn’t be teaching what are appropriate gender roles in a family!
I’ve honestly never given it a moments thought, but here’s one for you….I think I tend to assume cats are female and dogs are male…when I see a picture. Probably says something else very telling about me. I’m such a traitor to my gender, ha ha. I definitely agree with frollein….no long term damage done.
I do the same thing with cats and dogs! That’s probably because I relate to cats so much more. And I see dogs as just being so… uncivilized
Ha ha!
See, that’s what it’s like in german
Of course there are other biological words for a female dog or cat. But it’s true, you wouldn’t use it if you only see a picture and you’re not sure of the gender. Pigs and sheep are neutral. Cars and vehicles like that are also neutral. Ships are female. Big cars like trucks or busses are male. No idea why. Hard for english speaking people to learn but afterwards a lot easier.
That’s so interesting! Thanks for sharing
Pingback: The “dolls test”: On race, women, and inferiority « moments of exhilaration